V. Evidence card format
DEBATE RESOLUTION
Author, title, source date AFF/NEG/
Subtopic
“QUOTATION”
|
Evidence card sample
KAZAKHSTAN 2030 IS AN ATTAINABLE GOAL
Roman Vassilenko IS 0906 NEGATIVE
Low living standards in Kz
The unemployment rate in Kz is about 8 percent and
about 19 percent of the population lives below the poverty line.
The U.S. figures are less than 6 percent and 5 percent, respectively.
Official site of the RK Embassy in the US www.kazakhembus.com
VI. Speaker duties
Affirmative Constructive:
Intro (quote/state the resolution)
Define terms
State narrowed topic, if applicable
Preview in outline terms
State Contention 1 (preview subpoints)
State source and read evidence card
State Contention 2 (preview subpoints)
State source and read evidence card
Review main contentions
Give plan in terms of main planks/points
Point out its advantages/benefits
Summarize and ask for the ballot/vote
Negative Constructive:
1) Intro (quote/state the resolution)
2) Respond to definitions of terms (Grant or refute)
3) Respond to narrowed topic (if don’t agree, run the topicality argument)
4) Give generic preview
5) Refute Contention 1 and subpoints (see 4 points of refutation)
6) Attack evidence for Contention 1
7) Refute Contention 2 and subpoints (see 4 points of refutation)
8) Attack evidence for Contention 2
9) Sum up main points
10) Attack plan point by point
11) Attack advantages or give disadvantages
12) Sum up whole debate quickly and ask judge to vote for you
Refutation:
State word-for-word the opponent’s contention or point
State your response (I dis/agree…)
Introduce evidence and read source and tag,
Read evidence
Link your evidence to their argument
Tell judge that you destroyed or torpedoed their argument
Tell judge that the point goes to you
Достарыңызбен бөлісу: |